Rapid Response: Is an Explanation Needed for the Universe?
Blog Post
Rapid Response: Is an Explanation Needed for the Universe?

Objection: The Anthropic Principle Objection (APO hereafter) says we can only observe properties of a universe that is consistent with our existence. Therefore, we don’t need an explanation for why we observe a life-permitting universe, because it is the only kind of universe we could observe.

Response: The fact that we can only observe a life-permitting universe does nothing to dismiss the need for an explanation for the existence of a life-permitting universe. An illustration can help us see the problem with the APO

Imagine you’re arrested in a hostile country, convicted on false charges, sentenced to die by firing squad, and you’re blindfolded so you cannot anticipate your death. Two-hundred snipers are about to shoot you from point-blank range. You hear the command: “Ready! Aim! Fire!” The sounds of the rifles go off, and to your amazement—you’re alive. Two-hundred marksman missed from point-blank range! What would be your conclusion? “Well, I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that they all missed! After all, if they hadn’t all missed, I wouldn’t be here to be surprised about it! Nothing more to explain here!” :[1]

So, while it’s true that we shouldn’t be surprised that all we observe is a life-permitting universe since if it weren’t life-permitting we wouldn’t be able to observe it, we, nevertheless, should be astonished that against staggering odds, a life-permitting universe came to exist. And, we should wonder how it happened. I think the fine-tuning argument best explains it. What do you think?

[1] William Lane Craig. On Guard: Defending You Faith with Reason and Precision. (Colorado Spring: David C. Cook, 2010) pg, 116.

While You're Here
If you found this blog beneficial, consider donating to The Daily Apologist.
Donate Today
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Sign up to receive a monthly newsletter about the work of The Daily Apologist!

No spam, just helpful articles and insights. Unsubscribe anytime you’d like.

Providing Christians with intellectual and personal preparation needed to grow, proclaim, and defend the Christian worldview.

Newsletter Subscription
5016 Spedale Ct. #425
Spring Hill TN 37174
Phone Number
Working Hours
Mon – Fri: 9:00am – 5:00pm

2020 © All rights reserved. Please review our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy